Mycobacterium
tuberculosis
Disease
Epidemiology
In the
United States
,
overall case rates of TB disease are declining with approximately 15,000 new
cases reported in 2002 . HIV testing is recommended for suspected or confirmed
cases of TB, but this is not uniformly practiced. Therefore, the percentage of
TB patients with HIV-1 infection in the
United States
can
only be estimated. In 1999, approximately 10% of all TB cases in the
United States
were
known to be HIV-1 infected.
The
World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that TB is the cause of death for 11%
of all AIDS patients . The percentage and absolute number of patients with TB
disease who are HIV-1 infected is declining in the
United States
because
of improved infection-control practices and better diagnosis and treatment of
both HIV-1 infection and TB. With increased voluntary counseling and testing
and the increasing use of treatment for latent TB infection, TB disease will
probably continue to decrease among HIV-1--infected persons in the
United States
and
Western Europe
.
Persons
at high risk for TB in the
United States
include
injection-drug users, persons from high prevalence countries, and those who
live or work in congregate settings. TB disease occurs among HIV-1--infected
persons at all CD4+ T lymphocyte counts. The clinical manifestations
might be altered depending on the degree of immunosuppression.
Those with more advanced immunosuppression (CD4+ T lymphocyte count
<200 cells/µL) are more likely to
have extrapulmonary or disseminated disease. In areas where TB is endemic,
certain patients have higher CD4+ T lymphocyte counts at the time
HIV-1--related TB disease develops; in countries with low rates of TB disease
(e.g., United States and countries in Western Europe), more patients have
advanced HIV-1 disease at the time TB develops.
TB
disease in persons with HIV-1 infection can develop immediately after exposure
(i.e., primary disease) or as a result of progression after establishment of
latent TB infection (i.e., reactivation disease). Primary TB has been reported
in certain group outbreaks, particularly in persons with advanced immune
suppression, and might account for one third or more of cases of TB disease in
the HIV-infected population
Progression
to disease among those with latent TB infection is more likely among
HIV-1--infected than in HIV-uninfected persons. HIV-uninfected persons with a
positive tuberculin skin test (TST) result have a 5%--10% lifetime risk for
developing TB, compared with a 7%--10% annual risk in the HIV-1--infected
person with a positive TST result. Patients with TB disease have higher HIV-1
viral loads and a more rapid progression of their HIV-1 illness than comparable
HIV-1--infected patients without TB .
Clinical
Manifestations
The
clinical, radiographic, and histopathologic presentation of HIV-1--related TB
disease is heavily influenced by the degree of immunodeficiency). With CD4+
T lymphocyte counts >350 cells/µL,
HIV-1--related TB appears like TB among HIV-uninfected persons. The majority of
patients have disease limited to the lungs, and common chest radiographic
manifestations include upper lobe fibronodular infiltrates with or without
cavitation). However, extrapulmonary disease is more common in HIV-1--infected
persons than in non-HIV--infected persons. When extrapulmonary disease occurs
in HIV-1--infected persons, clinical manifestations are not substantially
different from those described in HIV-uninfected patients.
With
increasing degrees of immunodeficiency, extrapulmonary TB, with or without
pulmonary involvement, becomes more common. At CD4+ T lymphocyte
counts <50 cells/µL,
extrapulmonary TB (pleuritis, pericarditis, and meningitis) is common.
Among
severely immunocompromised patients, TB can be a severe systemic disease with
high fevers, rapid progression, and sepsis syndrome. The chest radiographic
findings of TB disease in advanced AIDS are markedly different compared with
those among patients with less severe HIV-1 infection; lower lobe, middle lobe,
and miliary infiltrates are common and cavitation is less common. Patients with
HIV-1 infection and pulmonary TB can have sputum smears and culture results
positive for acid-fast bacilli (AFB) or M.
tuberculosis, respectively, even with a normal chest radiograph.
Histopathological
findings are also affected by the degree of immunodeficiency. Patients with
relatively intact immune function have typical granulomatous inflammation
associated with TB disease. With progressive immunodeficiency, granulomas
become poorly formed or can be completely absent (189).
Diagnosis
Suspicion
of TB, and assiduous efforts to obtain appropriate diagnostic specimens are
important in diagnosing HIV-1--related TB disease. The evaluation of suspected
HIV-1-related TB should always include a chest radiograph. Sputum samples for
AFB smear and culture should be obtained from patients with pulmonary symptoms,
cervical adenopathy, or chest radiographic abnormalities. Sputum samples from a
substantial fraction of cases of pulmonary TB are negative by direct smear
microscopy.
Nucleic-acid
amplification (NAA) tests are useful in providing rapid identification of
M. tuberculosis from sputum smear-positive specimens, but
false-negative results can occur among patients with TB disease. The positive
predictive value of NAA tests are decreased in persons who have sputum
smear-negative results.
Among
patients with signs of extrapulmonary TB, needle aspiration of skin lesions,
nodes, pleural, or pericardial fluid might allow for rapid diagnosis, culture,
and susceptibility testing. Tissue biopsy is helpful among patients with
negative fine-needle aspirates. Among patients with signs of disseminated
disease, mycobacterial blood culture might allow a definitive diagnosis.
Mycobacterial blood culture is more sensitive for diagnosis of TB among
severely immunodeficient patients.
Among
patients with relatively intact immune function, the yield of sputum smear and
culture examinations is similar to that of HIV-uninfected adults, with positive
smear results being more common among patients with cavitary pulmonary
involvement (191). TST is positive
in the majority of patients with pulmonary disease and CD4+ T
lymphocyte counts >200 cells/µL.
Among patients with more severe immunodeficiency, sputum smear and culture
examinations become somewhat less sensitive, and TST has limited diagnostic
value because it is often negative (192).
However, the yield of mycobacterial stain and culture of specimens from
extrapulmonary sites (node aspirates and pleural and pericardial fluid) is
higher among patients with advanced immunodeficiency compared with
HIV-uninfected adults (193--195).
Smear-positive specimens from these sites probably represent a high burden of
organisms resulting from lack of effective immune response to mycobacteria and
inability to limit mycobacterial replication and kill the organisms.
A
positive smear result in any of these specimens (sputum, needle aspirate,
tissue biopsy) represents some form of mycobacterial disease but does not
always represent TB. However, because TB is the most virulent mycobacterial
pathogen and can be spread from person to person if pulmonary involvement is
present, patients with smear-positive results should be treated for TB disease
until definitive mycobacterial species identification is made.
Drug
susceptibility testing and adjustment of the treatment regimen based on the
results are critical to the successful treatment of TB and to prevention of
transmission of drug-resistant M.
tuberculosis in the community. Therefore, for all patients with TB
disease, testing for susceptibility to first line agents (isoniazid [INH],
rifampin [
RIF],
and ethambutol [EMB]) should be performed, regardless of the source of the
specimen. Pyrazinamide (PZA) susceptibility testing should be performed on an
initial isolate if there is a sufficiently high prevalence of PZA resistance in
the community. Second-line drug susceptibility testing should be performed only
in reference laboratories and should be limited to specimens from patients who
have had previous therapy, who are contacts of patients with drug-resistant TB
disease, who have demonstrated resistance to rifampin or to other first-line
drugs, or who have positive cultures after >3 months of treatment.
Treatment Recommendations
Treatment
of HIV--1-related TB disease should follow the general principles developed for
TB treatment among non-HIV--infected persons (AI).
Early diagnosis and treatment are critical. Because of the severity of TB
disease among immunocompromised patients, directly observed therapy (DOT) is
strongly recommended for patients with HIV-1--related TB (AI).
Multiple drugs and DOT are used to provide effective therapy, to prevent
acquired drug resistance during treatment, and to allow cure with a relatively
short course of treatment (6--9 months).
HIV-1--infected
patients have other social and medical needs and treatment success is enhanced
by a case-management approach, which incorporates assistance with all of these
needs (enhanced DOT) in addition to providing DOT.
Multiple
concerns should be considered in the treatment of HIV-1--associated TB disease.
First, treatment is effective, but the optimal duration of treatment is
uncertain. Second, acquired drug resistance is unusual with the use of DOT, but
does occur among HIV-1--infected persons. Third, the risk for acquired
rifamycin resistance has led to specific recommendations about dosing
frequency. Finally, the use of potent ART among patients being treated for TB
is complicated by overlapping drug toxicity profiles, drug-drug interactions,
and an increase in TB manifestations during immune reconstitution (paradoxical
reactions). Recent studies indicate that, with careful attention to these
complicating factors, the prognosis of HIV-1--associated TB disease can be
substantially improved with the provision of potent ART (AII),
although the optimal relative timing between anti-TB and HIV therapy is
uncertain.
Treatment
of drug susceptible TB disease in HIV-1--infected adults should include the use
of a 6-month regimen consisting of an initial phase of INH, RIF or rifabutin,
PZA, and EMB given for 2 months followed by INH and RIF (or rifabutin) for 4
months when the disease is caused by organisms known or presumed to be
susceptible to first-line anti-TB drugs ) (AI).
When the organism is susceptible to INH,
RIF,
and PZA, EMB should be discontinued (AI).
The
optimal duration of therapy for HIV-1--related TB disease remains
controversial. Studies in developing countries have shown that patients with
HIV-1--related TB respond well to standard 6-month treatment regimens, with
rates of treatment failure and relapse similar to those of HIV-uninfected
patients). However, it is unclear whether these results are applicable to
patients with advanced HIV-1 disease and TB. While awaiting definitive
randomized comparisons in HIV-1--infected patients with TB disease, 6 months of
therapy is probably adequate for the majority of cases, but prolonged therapy
(up to 9 months) is recommended (as in HIV-negative patients) for patients with
a delayed clinical or bacteriological response to therapy (symptomatic or
positive culture results at or after 2 months of therapy, respectively) or
perhaps with cavitary disease on chest radiograph (BII).
Intermittent
dosing (twice- or thrice- weekly) facilitates DOT by decreasing the total
number of encounters required between the patient and the provider, making
observed therapy more practical to deliver. However, once- or twice-weekly
dosing has been associated with an increased rate of acquired rifamycin
resistance among patients with advanced HIV-1 disease (CD4+ T
lymphocyte count <100 cells/µL).
Acquired rifamycin resistance was relatively common with once-weekly
rifapentine plus INH and also occurred in trials of twice-weekly rifabutin plus
INH and twice-weekly RIF plus INH Therefore,
once-weekly rifapentine is contraindicated among HIV-1--infected patients (EI),
and it is recommended that RIF- and rifabutin-based regimens be given at least
three times a week for patients with TB and advanced HIV-1 disease (CD4+
T lymphocyte count <100 cells/µL)
(AII). Although treatment
approaches to this population need to be further evaluated in prospective
trials, a prudent management strategy consists of daily DOT during the first 2
months of therapy and thrice-weekly DOT during the continuation phase of
anti-TB therapy (BII).
Monitoring
and Adverse Events
Close
follow-up, consisting of clinical, bacteriologic, and occasionally, laboratory
and radiographic evaluations, is essential to ensure treatment success. In
patients with pulmonary TB, at least one sputum specimen for microscopic
examination and culture should be obtained at monthly intervals until two
consecutive specimens are negative on culture (AII).
Drug susceptibility tests should be repeated on isolates from patients who have
positive cultures after 3 months of treatment. Patients who have positive
cultures after 4 months of treatment should be considered as having failed
therapy and managed accordingly. For patients with extrapulmonary TB, the
frequency and types of evaluations will depend on the sites involved and the
ease with which specimens can be obtained.
A
detailed clinical assessment should be performed at least monthly to identify
possible medication intolerance and to assess adherence. As a routine,
monitoring blood tests for patients being treated with first-line drugs unless
baseline abnormalities were identified is unnecessary (AII).
More frequent clinical and laboratory monitoring is indicated for patients with
underlying liver disease, including hepatitis C co-infection.
INH,
RIF, and PZA all can cause drug-induced hepatitis, and the risk might be
increased in patients taking other potentially hepatotoxic agents or in persons
with underlying liver dysfunction. However, because of the effectiveness of
these drugs (particularly INH and RIF), they should be used, if at all
possible, even in the presence of preexisting liver disease (AIII).
Frequent clinical and laboratory monitoring should be performed to detect any
exacerbation.
Independent
of HIV status for all patients with TB disease, multiple treatment options
exist if serum aminotransaminases are >3 times the upper limit of normal
before the initiation of treatment, and the abnormalities are not thought to be
caused by TB disease. One option is to use standard therapy with frequent
monitoring. A second option is to treat with RIF, EMB, and PZA for 6 months,
avoiding INH (BII). A third option
is to treat with INH and RIF for 9 months, supplemented by EMB for the first 2
months, thereby avoiding PZA (BII).
Among patients with severe liver disease, a regimen with only one hepatotoxic
agent, generally RIF plus EMB, can be given for 12 months, preferably with
another agent, such as a fluoroquinolone, for the first 2 months (CIII).
As previously indicated, treatment might need to be lengthened for patients who
are HIV-1-infected. For patients who develop worsening hepatic function on
treatment, a specialist should be consulted.
Tests
to monitor hepatotoxicity (aminotransferases, bilirubin, and alkaline
phosphatase), renal function (serum creatinine), and platelet count should be
obtained for all patients started on treatment for TB. At each monthly visit,
patients taking EMB should be asked about possible visual disturbances
including blurred vision or scotomata. Monthly testing of visual acuity and
color discrimination is recommended for patients taking doses that, on a
milligram per kilogram basis, are greater than those listed in recommended
doses and for patients receiving the drug for >2 months.
Patients
with TB disease caused by strains of M.
tuberculosis resistant to at least INH and RIF (multidrug-resistant
[MDR]) are at high risk for treatment failure and further acquired drug
resistance. Such patients should be referred to or have consultation obtained
from specialized treatment centers as identified by the local or state health
departments or CDC. Although patients with strains resistant to RIF alone have
a better prognosis than patients with MDR strains, they are also at increased
risk for treatment failure and additional resistance and should be managed in
consultation with an expert.